Creative Technology Careers, Foothills Medical Centre Parking, Ardell Brow Gel, Endertale Page 16, Words To Describe Insects, Pros And Cons Of Malpractice Insurance For Nurse Practitioners, Matthew 20 Commentary, Psalm 116 Meaning, Yolo Shortline 1233, Woodstock, Ct Farm Stands, Dhairya Opposite Word In Kannada, " /> Creative Technology Careers, Foothills Medical Centre Parking, Ardell Brow Gel, Endertale Page 16, Words To Describe Insects, Pros And Cons Of Malpractice Insurance For Nurse Practitioners, Matthew 20 Commentary, Psalm 116 Meaning, Yolo Shortline 1233, Woodstock, Ct Farm Stands, Dhairya Opposite Word In Kannada, " />

can dogs see red

It is extremely helpful for me. Reduced-color vision is a huge benefit to a carnivorous animal; even omnivorous bears, who largely scavenge rather than hunt, have reduced color spectrum vision. The color red appears dark brownish gray or black to dogs. He must have been colour-cogniscient because he steadfastly refused to retrieve orange, pink, yellow, pink or magenta ones! The Shih Tsu, in my experience is the calmer one. I'm trying to teach my pup diff colors, so now I know his black bone looks the same as his red ball!!!! I have a set of balls exactly the same of different colors, yellow, red, orange and neon pink. Even though your article was very interesting, I am perplexed because, out of my 3 dogs, one sees red very well. Or else I just have a super intelligent dog, which for other reasons I am startng to think that. Dogs have fewer cones than humans, which suggests that their color vision won't be as rich or intense as ours. Rods, which are extremely sensitive cells that catch movement and work in low light. For dogs, their color vision is most similar to a human with red-green color blindness, although there are other differences. Instead of seeing the rainbow as violet, blue, blue-green, green, yellow, orange, and red, … But the dogs see the letters as characters. Mark Siebel Dogs can make out yellow and blue, and combinations of those colors. I googled your article because I had always heard that dogs can't see red. Why are so many people drawn to conspiracy theories in times of crisis? The longest lived domestic cat was named Creme Puff. Do People Everywhere Feel Blue and Turn Green with Envy? Lv 4. vor 4 Jahren. Blue-green is seen as gray. You may have even done it with your pup. That means that when your own pet version of Lassie runs right past the toy that you tossed, she may not be stubborn or stupid. This helped me alot. Cats and dogs have evolved to be superbly designed for night-time hunting. However they can still … Red to them is a light pink and green is white to them.So yes, dogs can see colour it is un-true about being colour blind. © The American Kennel Club, Inc. 2020. In agility, for example, what colors the obstacles are painted makes a difference in whether the dog can see them clearly and thus be safer on the course. Similarly, they often perceive green as grey. It may be your fault for choosing a toy with a color that is hard to discriminate from the green grass of your lawn. Thanx. She lived from August 3, 1967 to August 6, 2005, a span of 38 years and 3 days. Even spelling some of what she wrote would trouble some adults! What if they needed this to see better in the dark to hunt? I have always wondered how they can say any animal see's this way or that way. There are children reading this, why did you post such a stupid comment? Instead a rainbow made up of red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet, they see a study in shades of khaki, ranging from brown through yellow and mustard to blue. When your dog is looking for his yellow tennis ball on green grass, he sees shades of light yellow. For more about that click here. Dogs, like most mammals, are dichromats -- possesing two types of cones in their retina for color perception and ability to see details. I have to say the people/canine vision scale was the most useful and easiest to understand. Now that you know that dogs don’t see certain colors, it would make sense to choose products for them that feature the colors they can see. This is what makes them color blind, although they actually can make out some hues. In the last few decades, examinations of the canine eye structure have revealed some differences in basic design between humans and dogs. Laser pointers may initially seem like a great way to exercise your dog. It is caused by abnormalities in color-detecting molecules, known as cones, in the retina. I actually have a dog -- a hunting dog -- and I don't think they would need to see all of the colors we do. This means that they cannot distinguish between green, red and yellow objects based upon their colour. “It’s likely that all the external world appears to them as varying highlights of black and gray,” Judy wrote in his 1937 manual, “Training the Dog.”. they have less of a need for seeing colors, "I wonder why dogs have such a limited vision of color. and to the excellent answer posted by anonymous on April 18 2010, the reason fruit eaters have particularly good colour vision, is that they need to know if the fruit is ripe or not. Being dichromatic means that a dog’s perception of color will be limited … Dogs and humans see and experience color differently. They can see various shades of blue and can differentiate between closely related shades of gray that are not distinguishable to people. Regards, In the 1960s, other researchers hypothesized that the only mammals that can discern color are primates. The retina is a lining at the back of the eye that converts light into electrical impulses. For many test trials, dogs were shown three light panels in a row, two of the panels were the same color, while the third was different. We have a red laser pointer and my daughter was shining it on the floor and one of my dogs started chasing it. That bright red velvet cushion? They see red as a shade of gray. In humans, the defect in red-green perception is the most common form of color deficiency. They probably think (if they do think at all--many argue about this) that they have a full spectrum!! There was little research to back up these assertions, especially the one about dogs. Cats (and dogs) have a high concentration of rod receptors and a low concentration of cone receptors. That's what I'm teaching my dog next. You have taught him the sound 'red' means 'that one'. AKC Family Dog columnist Stanley Coren offered this observation: “The most popular colors for dog toys today are red or orange. It allows them to focus on shape and movement instead of being distracted by color. Why would a dog want to see such a bright light hunting? The eyes of both people and dogs contain special light catching cells called cones that respond to color. Dogs can see the color blue, but violet shades appear blue to them. I hope this answers your questoin!!! dog shop. They do tests. This does not mean that dogs can't see green or red objects! The Pawprints of History. However, I always feel that my dog can recognize things by their smell. Unlike humans who have three different colour sensitive cone cells in their retina (red, green and blue) dogs have only two (yellow and blue). Next time your dog runs past a bright red toy sitting on top of vivid green grass, remember your dog sees various shades of yellow. Dogs don't see red, purple (violet), or orange as we do. The yellow ball that they play with most will smell completely different to the neon pink one that they don't. We can get an idea of what dogs see, Neitz said, if we assume their brains interpret signals from their cone cells much like the brains of color-blind people. In fact, dogs live in a pretty colorful world. Can Dogs See Red. I want to know if you guys sale dogs because i really want one. While dogs can't appreciate all the colors that humans do, their world is not entirely black and white. I have a year old Shitzu and according tpo the topic on color and the spectrum illustrated for dogs, I certainly cannot agree that dogs only see certain clors. A lot more colorfully than you might have imagined, new research suggests. Genetic Memories, Some Fears in Dogs May Be Innate, What's Your Favorite Color? She has accetped the red bull over the orange cat. 0 1 0. :-D. If you really want to turn it into an experiment try it with other colors of light and see if you get different results. How do you know? Thank you so much I just love dogs I have a Lhasa apso but she is so active and Lhasas ,I read, Are supposed to be calm any info on that?????? Blue green shades appear gray to dogs. Evolution and function have driven these differences. But our best buds don't need to see things like stoplights and business signs. They only play with the old one. The most common types of human colorblindness come about because the person is missing one of the three kinds of cones. You can tell from the structure of their eyeball. Yes, like us, our dogs can see in color. Some people are complete idiots I swear - where's your scientific fact Gale?! I know this because I run a pet shop and sell lots of toys and get lots of feedback from customers. Left: Human view of a dog with a orange, red, and yellow rop in his mouth. This knowledge may help explain why some dogs go crazy over yellow tennis balls, but are apathetic about the same ball in pink or red. Humans and a few other primate species are trichromatic, which means they have three kinds of cones. “They also have more rods, which improves low-light vision, in the retina.”. He sees a nearly black ball. Thank you for your information. Also, since red is interpreted as a 'danger' sign by humans, and it's well established that dog behaviour is much learned from humans it's no wonder they frequently ignore red toys, even if they do appear a different color. AKC actively advocates for responsible dog ownership and is dedicated to advancing dog sports. I'm only 11, but I think that dogs serve no purpose of seeing completely. I read this article and thought OK cool so that's how it is. As for why the other two don't they see it they just don't care to chase it. Dogs do see in color, but their perception of color is not the same as it is for people. Other animals see far more colours than us. Dogs do see colors, but the colors that they see are neither as rich nor as many as those seen by humans. Stanley Coren is the author of many books including Why Do Dogs Have Wet Noses? Cones that work in bright light and control color perception. But labeling such as color vision is incorrect (popular "science") because most any scientific text on color and vision will define color as a process that is created in human eyes and is sorted out in human brains. That leaves us with the question as to whether dogs actually use the color vision abilities that they have. In many ways, dogs and people see the world differently. It's true. Unfortunately, they can cause serious problems for their future. i love golden retrievers.Those are my fave gods.i always wanted one.i hope you guys sale dogs.sooooo i need to go goooooood bye ps i am sorry if i spell something wrong. 0 0 0. Red will appear brown to dogs, pink will show itself as gray and green will turn yellow. Dogs developed their senses as nocturnal hunters, tracking and catching their food at night. Dogs See Fewer Colors Than We Do While scientists used to believe that dogs were color blind, turns out your dog can see colors, but with a different spectrum. Yes, dogs do see in color — but their color spectrum is more muted and muddy than what we see. So, while it is established that dogs see shades of yellow, blue and gray, if a dog were to look at a uniform that is red or green it would appear as faded brownish, gray or indistinct. http://news.nationalgeographic.co.uk/news/2008/05/080519-shrimp-colors.html. Dogs see color as humans with red-green color blindness do. Each type of cone registers a different light wavelength. Only a few branches of the family tree, like us Old World Primates, have 3. Dogs can see shades of blue, yellow, and gray. For example, behavioural tests in dogs suggest that they can distinguish red from blue, but often confuse red and green. Whether dogs are color blind may have been long debated but solid research carried out by scientists have confirmed the fact that dogs can see beyond black and white trashing a once popular belief that dogs can only see tinges of gray. But, they can see a variety of shades of blue, and can even tell between very […] Even on the internet the question concerning dog vision is discussed controversial. I swap them around regularly. Humans don't particularly like brightness, so why would dogs??? This means that they cannot distinguish between green, red and yellow objects based upon their colour. That lush green lawn? This is supported in humans as well: the very rare completely colorblind humans have sight like a hawk's - literally. It may be your fault for choosing a toy with a color that is hard to discriminate from the green grass of your lawn.”. What kind of comment was that? I suspect they can see well beyond humans' and into the infra-red wavelengths. dogs have a far better sense of smell than humans and can hear far better than humans. Dogs are dichromatic, and have only two types. We can get an idea of what dogs see, Neitz said, if we assume their brains interpret signals from their cone cells much like the brains of color-blind people. Great article!! I read somewhere they see more colors than dogs but less than humans. If they have the same rods and cones as us, the same physical equipment, what makes you think they see any differently? The simple answer, namely that dogs are colorblind, has been misinterpreted by people as meaning that dogs see no color, but only shades of gray. Some can also read. That would be the evolutionary/creationistic reason for their limited visual spectrum. For example, behavioural tests in dogs suggest that they can distinguish red from blue, but often confuse red and green. I was once owned by a mixed-breed tom who loved to retrieve (which is already an anomaly) red gift bows. Dogs can't see the full range of the color spectrum, but that doesn't mean they can't see colors at all. However red is difficult for dogs to see. Color Vision for Dog’s. Seeing in many shades and kinds of color works primarily for frugivores and non-ruminant herbivores like tropical seed-eating birds. If I notice a toy is becoming a favourite I rush out and buy another identical one. Dog Vision offers an online tool to help you see things as your dog sees them. But, dogs can see colors. That's what I suspected except I'm using a RED ball which is OK for me but obviously not helpful to my dog.. Blue, I guess would be the best colour for her ball. Quelle(n): https://shorte.im/bbZSy. That idea was widely accepted for decades, but new research and conclusions about canine anatomy and behavior have shown that while dogs can’t see the same colors humans do, they can still see some colors. Technicolor may be beyond their comprehension, but research shows that the dog’s eye can see much more than shades of gray. Scientists now believe that a dog’s color vision is similar to that of a person who has red-green color blindness, according to research conducted by Jay Neitz, who runs the Neitz Color Vision Lab in the Department of Ophthalmology at the University of Washington. This is the situation for dogs who also have only two kinds of cones. Anmelden, um etwas auf Antworten zu erwidern Veröffentlichen; gripp. Cats and dogs have evolved to be superbly designed for night-time hunting. However they can still distinguish a red ball from a green one if there is a difference in the perceived brightness of the two. How Resilient Are Dogs to Stressful Experiences? How green and red … These signals are then conveyed, through the optic nerve, to the brain, where an image is formed. Dogs can see colour but the only colours they can't see is red and green. This is a test to see if a dog can see a red laser dot. All rights reserved. dt. Actually, both color and smell can effect a dog. You are mistaken. Keep going, don't ever stop setting your own levels. I she is asked to fetch the red one with them all lying in the same vicinity she heads directly for the red one. All of these colors look yellowish to a dog. For dogs, their color vision is most similar to a human with red-green color blindness, although there are other differences. Any shade … Dogs also tend to be nearsighted to varying degrees. Your other dogs aren't as interested. Therefore, their eyes adapted to see well in the dark and to catch movement. The crazy thing for me is how there is 1 person on here saying that this article is wrong and that dogs don't see colour - they can only see black and white! The notion that dogs see only in shades of black and white has been attributed to Will Judy, a lifelong dog fancier, writer, and past publisher of Dog Week magazine. Humans have the opposite, which why we can't see as well at night but can … Myth. And you’ll understand why she gets distracted during a game of fetch as she hones in on a bird flying 50 yards away. They see the colors green, yellow, and orange as yellowish, and they see violet and blue as blue. They see anything on a scale of yellow and blue, and they have lower than humans’ distinction of brightness. Neitz confirmed that dogs actually do see color, but many fewer colors than normal humans do. Neitz confirmed that dogs actually do see color, but many fewer colors than normal humans do. My 5 pets shield from brightness, poor guys and gals. If you don't understand the physics and biology of sight and light and colour, you are missing out on an amazing story. Who Most Wants to Get Back Together With an Ex? Your description certainly explains why virtually all of the dogs I see at the local animal shelter never bother to sheild their eyes from the sun - they will happily catch a treat thrown towards them in direct sunlight. My dog Zenna is a chichuahua, I bought her 2 dog toys similar to each other with long stems coming up, one is a orange cat and one is a red bull. Dogs can see the color blue, but violet shades appear blue to them. These may be some reasons why our creator decided to create these magnificent creatures that way. Dogs can be easily trained to tell the difference between certain colors even though they don’t see them in the same way as people. But there is a simple answer to that question which I would like to share with you supported by some scientific resources. This does not mean that dogs can't see green or red objects! You see this effect when buying a new replacement toy sometimes. Nevertheless, it soon became apparent that our canine pals are color blind. For color to be seen, there needs to be an object which reflects wavelengths that stimulate the cones in human eyes, when, of course, the object is illuminated by a light source. I have found some of them to be agressive towards other dogs. So dogs can see yellow and blue, but no green or red or colors created by these shades, such as pink, orange or purple. I understand what you are saying when you contend that dog (and undoubtedly other creatures) "see" color because most will see portions of the electromagnetic spectrum and react appropriately. 11 years young and analytical, well spoken/written, and still with a child's perspective. It depends on you Lhasa and it's personality, the ones I have had were very active. I really enjoyed this artical and I so glad that my dogs DO see color! This article is based on tests and scientific fact. Have you ever noticed dog agility equipmentis usually blue and yellow? However, the trick to seeing color is not just having cones, but having several different types of cones, each tuned to different wavelengths of light. The Pawprints of History. Stanley Coren, Ph.D., FRSC., is a professor of psychology at the University of British Columbia. Actually "Writing Frontier" , seeing colors is a big deal for those of us who compete in dog sport. We’ve all seen the videos of dogs (and cats) chasing that elusive red dot. Right: The same scene through canine eyes, as interpreted through the Dog Vision Image Processing Tool. So they are … The best color for dog toys is blue, especially if it’s for outdoor play. There are also apps that you can use to see what your dog is seeing at any time. The question if dogs are colorblind, specifically red-green colorblind or if dogs only see shades of gray is raised among dog owners quite often. When tossing the yellow ball to her which she returns and then throwing the pink color she certainly indicates that it is not the one she returned. I'd love to hear how you progress with that kind of iq level as it is often difficult for the intelligent ones amongst us to not stand out from the crowd. Knowing how and what your dog can see will help you make good choices for her. “Most dogs can’t see much of red or green at all,” says Dr. Satchu. They confused scarlet with green and pink with blue. That way favourite toys last twice as long, or I have another if one gets lost. Dogs do see colors albeit not as bright or many in number compared to the human visual spectrum. Their eyes contain three types of light-sensitive cones -- blue-, green- and red-sensitive -- which allows enjoyment of all colors in the visible spectrum. I hope to God you don't own any animals!! They’re marked in medium blue and y… The retina is where scientists have also found the key to the difference in color perception between dogs and people. Fantastic Emma. They mainly see blues, yellows, and grays,” says Dr. Nelson. You can see what the spectrum looks like to people and dogs below. If dogs cannot see red, how come she loves the red bull? Since He created the many things on earth for our enjoyment- the wonderful taste of food, the dazzling smell of freshly cut flowers, the beautiful awe-inspiring sight of the grassy hill-tops- one might wonder why He created this unique creature with a limited range of seeing color. Unlike humans who have three different color sensitive cone cells in their retina (red, green and blue) dogs have only two (yellow and blue) [3,4]. What dogs can see on the screen is also different to humans. See the color chart below for an … Why argue?! hi i love dogs. Dogs can't tell the difference between orange, yellow and green. You can't deny a fact! Dogs do see in color, but their perception of color is not the same as it is for people. Hi all, I'd just like to say thank you for the very informative webpage, it is awesome that the web has provided us with a means of indulging our quest for knowledge. Many birds see in more shades of color than humans do, actually. This will help ALL dog owners to the ability of their dogs sight, and how dogs actually see color, AND for the best color toys to buy them!! A lot of people get them mixed up. Snakes have infra-red sensitive "pits" on their heads which allow them to see infra-red radiation just as we see normal light. Your dog doesn't. He loves trying to bite the little red light on the floor or walls. Meanwhile, there are some types of fish and birds that can see an even broader range of the color spectrum than people can. This means dogs see the world in different colors than humans. Cones, rod etc. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on dogs colorblindness. Or what if they couldn't handle seeing the wide-range of colors like we do? This means that that bright red dog toy that is so visible to you may often be difficult for your dog to see. They are very good at distinguishing between variations of blues and yellows, but cannot really see red and green all that well. See Writing Frontier's "Shocking Dog Tale" at, http://writingfrontier.com/2008/10/12/smart-dog/. Cats and dogs can see in the pitch dark. Also, the colors we see and dogs don't are pretty bright. Dog Vision, a website devoted to canine color perception, printed this side-by-side comparison of how people and dogs register the color spectrum. Get the help you need from a therapist near you–a FREE service from Psychology Today. For example, you should keep your dog’s color range in mind when shopping for toys. My other two dogs are oblivious to it. Instead of seeing the rainbow as violet, blue, blue-green, green, yellow, orange, and red, dogs would see it as dark blue, light blue, gray, light yellow, darker yellow (sort of brown), and very dark gray. I have aways wanted to know about this ever since I was a child and someone told me that dogs were colorblind, and of course I thought literally. The human eyes criterion is the key to the definition of color vision. The dogs' task was to find the one that was different and to press that panel. The retina is composed of millions of light-sensing cells. I have a hunting dog,and he is very interested in laser pointer spot. As already mentioned, our trichromatic vision enables us to see red, green, and blue. They have difficulty with green, orange and red. This is wrong. https://www.akc.org/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php, https://www.akc.org/subscription/thank-you. iy_2020; im_12; id_05; ih_19; imh_43; i_epoch:1607226192340, py_2020; pm_11; pd_11; ph_01; pmh_49; p_epoch:1605088177987, link-block-publisher; link-block-publisher_link-block-publisher; bodystr, pn_tstr:Wed Nov 11 01:49:37 PST 2020; pn_epoch:1605088177987. Making Sacrifices For Your Dog’s Happiness. That means that when your own pet version of Lassie runs right past the toy that you tossed she may not be stubborn or stupid. That has become their favorite game. One amusing or odd fact is that the most popular colors for dog toys today are red or safety orange (the bright orange-red on traffic cones or safety vests). Additionally, full color vision is a humongous detriment to any animal that hunts: any animal who has full color vision will not be a natural meat-eater, regardless of social bias. Myth. Dogs can see in the dark and it is one of the most important characteristics they have, therefore, they are great night hunters. How dogs see color is a long-standing topic of research and the results are pretty amazing. Try it for yourself. Answer a few simple questions and find the right dog for you, Compare up to 5 different breeds side by side, Browse the AKC Marketplace to find the right puppy for you, Browse our extensive library of dog names for inspiration, Find out the best and worst foods for your dog and which to avoid, 8 percent of men and 0.5 percent of women, The popular notion that dogs only see in black and white is incorrect, Dogs can make out yellow and blue, and combinations of those colors, This means the best toys for your dog may be those in blue and yellow hues. Neitz confirmed that dogs actually do see color, but many fewer colors than normal humans do. Also examining the structure of the eyes would yeild clues as to the way the eye sees. A green laser pointer is very cool and convenient, I have bought 3 pens and recommended laser pointer to my friends. Copyright SC Psychological Enterprises Ltd. May not be reprinted or reposted without permission. Dogs, and some color-blind people, are missing red-green cones. Color is human perception of spectral radiation. So dogs can see yellow and blue, but no green or red or colors created by these shades, such as pink, orange or purple. The eyes of both people and dogs contain special light catching cells called cones that respond to color. Jay Neitz at the University of California, Santa Barbara, tested the color vision of dogs. Then another complete disbeliever in Mary! Dogs see the colors of the world as basically yellow, blue, and gray. If you’re out and about, your dog’s eyes can get red from smog, drift from crop-spraying, cigarette smoke and other toxins. Then we have arguments over creationism and evolution! The dog's pupil has a great capacity for expansion and that allows the retina to receive more stimulation the milder the light is. The new one might be identical except for a little less wear, but they won't touch it. It only means that they can't distinguish green, yellow or red objects based on their color. But dogs are believed to see only shades of yellow, blue, and gray. The one for red and green gives humans their appreciation for a red rose or a Granny Smith apple. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It probably looks like a field of dead hay. A poodle, for example, is estimated to have what we would call 20/75 … ", It's not just dogs, placental mammals in general have only 2 color receptors. These include: Dogs have more rods than cones in their retina, whereas people have more cones, and this apparently makes the difference in color perception. It's not perfect mind you there is still the matter of the brain processing the data from the eyes but once again examining the structure of the brain and tests done on it can yield the clues needed to assemble a picture of how the animal sees things. There are many types of birds and fish that are tetrachromatic — they have a fourth type of cone receptor to absorb ultraviolet light. You want the sole focus to be on the color if that's what you are interested in. Dogs have dichromatic vision – they have two types of colour receptor cells and see … See colors? "Dogs do have fewer color sensitive cone receptors in their retinas than their human counterparts," says Dr. Martin Goldstein, an integrative veterinarian and author of The Nature of Healing Animals. 4 Reasons Why You Should Express Gratitude Every Day, Psychology Today © 2020 Sussex Publishers, LLC, A Memory Exercise to Rekindle Your Relationship’s Romance, CBT-E and FBT for Adolescents With an Eating Disorder, Noise Pollution Hampers Animal Communication, Why Do Dogs Have Wet Noses? Humans are much more complex creatures and strangely need to see all of this. They can see various shades of blue and can differentiate between closely related shades of gray that are not distinguishable to people. Dogs can't tell the difference between orange, yellow and green. I'm a Christian but I do not restrict myself to only believing in what the bible says! She will enjoy yellow and blue toys more than red ones. This is a perfect example of the "Nested Hierarchies" that we use to describe evolutionary history :-). Both humans and dogs have these, but dogs have many more rods in their eyes, allowing them to see much better in lower light conditions. He claimed to be the first to declare that dogs had poor vision and thought they were able to see single shades and tones and only general outlines and shapes. As a matter of fact, dogs can’t distinguish between yellow, orange, red, or green.

Creative Technology Careers, Foothills Medical Centre Parking, Ardell Brow Gel, Endertale Page 16, Words To Describe Insects, Pros And Cons Of Malpractice Insurance For Nurse Practitioners, Matthew 20 Commentary, Psalm 116 Meaning, Yolo Shortline 1233, Woodstock, Ct Farm Stands, Dhairya Opposite Word In Kannada,

Leave a Reply